- How will you lead the investigation considering customs and values of the society?
- How will you collaborate with civil administration and tea garden authority for education and awareness of the people?
- What may be your ethical dilemma in nabbing the culprits?
- What may be your suggestions to eradicate the social evils like witch hunting?
In addressing the situation as Superintendent of Police in a district facing a witch-hunting incident, it is essential to navigate the investigation with cultural sensitivity, collaborative efforts, ethical integrity, and proactive measures to eradicate such social evils.
A. Leading the Investigation with Sensitivity to Local Customs and Values
To ensure a fair and effective investigation that respects the community’s traditions:
- Balanced Enforcement: Pursue the investigation impartially, ensuring that justice is served while remaining sensitive to cultural norms to avoid further conflict. Engaging community leaders to build trust and reduce resistance during the investigation is essential.
- Community-Led Fact-Finding: Involve local representatives in information-gathering, ensuring transparency and avoiding escalation. This aligns with the 2nd Administrative Reforms Commission’s (ARC) emphasis on inclusive, community-oriented policing.
- Education and Dialogue: Host open dialogues to address local superstitions around witchcraft, explaining the legal consequences and encouraging cooperation with law enforcement.
B. Collaboration with Civil Administration and Tea Garden Authorities for Education and Awareness
To address root causes of the incident like illiteracy, lack of awareness, and inadequate welfare:
- Educational Campaigns: Collaborate with the District Collector and NGOs to introduce regular literacy and awareness programs, focusing on eradicating superstitions like witch-hunting. This initiative could be aligned with schemes such as Saakshar Bharat Mission to improve literacy.
- Welfare Monitoring: Work with tea garden authorities to ensure they fulfill their responsibilities, such as healthcare, education, and employment welfare. The Plantations Labour Act, 1951 mandates such welfare provisions, which can improve living conditions and reduce susceptibility to harmful practices.
- Social Support Centers: Set up support and counseling centers within tea gardens to educate workers about government welfare schemes like MGNREGA for employment, Ayushman Bharat for health, and PM Awas Yojana for housing.
C. Ethical Dilemmas in Nabbing the Culprits
An ethical dilemma may arise due to the following:
- Community Retribution vs. Justice: Arresting individuals based on traditional beliefs could create tensions, potentially alienating the community. While justice is essential, the approach must avoid excessive penalization and focus on reform.
- Role of Instigators vs. Followers: Differentiating between the instigators who knowingly perpetuate superstitions for power and those who, due to ignorance or social pressure, participated in the act. Holding instigators accountable while showing leniency to those misled by superstition may better balance justice with compassion.
D. Suggestions to Eradicate Social Evils like Witch-Hunting
A multi-faceted approach is necessary for sustainable change:
- Stringent Law Enforcement: Apply the Assam Witch Hunting (Prohibition, Prevention, and Protection) Act, 2015 strictly, ensuring timely prosecution and establishing that such acts will be met with serious consequences.
- Community Awareness Drives: Conduct awareness campaigns with civil society to dispel superstitions and emphasize scientific reasoning, focusing on school children, youth groups, and workers within tea gardens.
- Empowering Local Leaders: Train and engage local influencers, such as tea garden supervisors, teachers, and healthcare workers, to act as advocates against witch-hunting practices.
- Long-Term Socio-Economic Upliftment: Coordinate with state agencies to introduce skill-development programs, vocational training, and employment schemes to reduce economic dependence on tea gardens and encourage self-reliance, reducing the community’s susceptibility to social evils.
In leading this initiative, my role would be to embody Nolan’s principles of leadership and accountability, ensuring that the measures taken respect the community’s well-being and aim to foster a safe, progressive, and empowered society.
Check out UPSC Coaching Centre Guwahati | APSC Coaching Centre Guwahati | Crack APSC Exam | UPSC Civil Services Exam | Ethics Paper in UPSC Exams
